Mass poaching of a competitor’s staff constitutes an act of unfair competition […].

Mass poaching of a competitor’s staff resulting in its disorganization constitutes an act of unfair competition.

Cass., Com, April 13, 2023, no. 22-12.808

In its ruling of April 13, 2023, the French Supreme Court affirms that hiring a competitor’s staff, even though they are released from their non-competition clause, constitutes an act of unfair competition if it results in the company’s disorganization.

 

1. The legal framework

Under Articles 1240 and 1241 of the French Civil Code, acts of unfair competition may give rise to extra-contractual liability on the part of the perpetrator.

While in principle the hiring of a competitor’s employees is clearly an act of unfair competition when the latter are bound by non-competition clauses, the French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) reminds us in this ruling that even without a clause, employers can be bound, under certain conditions.

 

2. The facts

In this case, a company hired the former technical director of a competitor.

He will then contact employees of his former employer to offer them the chance to join the company he has joined. These steps led to the poaching of four employees.

His new employer was therefore sued for damages for unfair competition. He appealed on the grounds that the employees had not been subject to a non-competition clause, thus ruling out any unlawful or disloyal character that might be attached to their hiring.

In a ruling dated January 13, 2022, the Court of Appeal rejected his claim, arguing that the poaching had been accompanied by unfair maneuvers which had resulted in the disorganization of the competitor’s business. These maneuvers were characterized by the fact that the first employee hired had contacted half the company’s staff in an attempt to poach them, and that the four employees actually poached made up the entire “quality” department, resulting in a profound disorganization of the company’s structure. In this case, the company had difficulty in replacing the staff it had poached, and its business slowed considerably as a result.

 

3. The opinion of the Court of Cassation

The Cour de cassation rejected the appeal ruling, holding that although they were not bound by a non-competition clause, the mass poaching of a competitor’s staff with the effect of causing its disorganization constituted an act of unfair competition.

You may also be interested in this news
L’Actu By NMCG – January 2024
News By NMCG
L'Actu By NMCG - January 2024
Lawyer profile: Vaea Pery
Inside NMCG
Lawyer profile: Vaea Pery
Finance Act for 2024
Article
Finance Act for 2024
Compensation for bodily injury and moral prejudice in constant evolution
Article
Compensation for bodily injury and moral prejudice in constant evolution
Chairman’s fraud: liability of a victim company’s bank for breach of its duty of care
Article
Chairman's fraud: liability of a victim company's bank for breach of its duty of care
Optimize your assets: Discover the potential of contribution-cession!
Article
Optimize your assets: Discover the potential of contribution-cession!
The main social measures introduced by the Finance Act for 2024 […]
Article
The main social measures introduced by the Finance Act for 2024 [...]
Following a transfer, the new employer cannot be held responsible […].
Article
Following a transfer, the new employer cannot be held responsible [...].
Alcohol consumption and drug testing: jurisprudence applies a common sense approach to facts
Article
Alcohol consumption and drug testing: jurisprudence applies a common sense approach to facts
One everywhere, proof in the middle
Article
One everywhere, proof in the middle
The employer’s failure to organize paid leave […].
Article
The employer's failure to organize paid leave [...].
Creation of a Tax Law Department
Press release
Creation of a Tax Law Department
Judicial statistics NMCG – 2023
Inside NMCG
Judicial statistics NMCG - 2023
The town doctor, collaborating with the occupational health and prevention service
Article
The town doctor, collaborating with the occupational health and prevention service
Competition restrictions, beware of abuse (ROLEX & MARIAGE FRERES)!
Article
Competition restrictions, beware of abuse (ROLEX & MARIAGE FRERES)!
Confirmation of Jurisprudence on inexcusable fault, Social Security Financing Bill 2024
Article
Confirmation of Jurisprudence on inexcusable fault, Social Security Financing Bill 2024
The Distinctions