How should an employer act if an employee […]?

Employment Law News – March 2023

On March 1st, 2023, the Court of Cassation recalled that “the employer is obliged to pay his remuneration and to provide work to the employee who is at his disposal”, even if the employee had a great deal of freedom of organization in his schedule.

In this case, an employee had filed a claim for back pay with the labour court, and requested that her dismissal be reclassified as an unjustified dismissal, arguing that her contract provided for an effective monthly working time of 60 hours, but that in practice, she carried out her assignments for a shorter period, and was therefore paid pro rata.

The Court of Appeal dismissed his claims on the grounds:

  • a totally free organization of her schedule, since she chose her hours according to her convenience;
  • the absence of proof that the company had asked him not to work the contractual number of hours, nor that it had opposed his arrival;
  • that it was not established that the failure to complete the scheduled number of hours resulted from a failure to provide assignments.

Clearly, according to the Court of Appeal, the burden of proof was on the employee.

The Court of Cassation censured the decision and considered that it was up to the employer to prove that he had actually provided both the work and the salary agreed upon, regardless of the freedom of organization that was granted.

If the employee does not work the set number of hours, it is up to the employer to prove that the employee did not make himself available or that he refused to perform the tasks required of him.

Cass. soc., March 1st, 2023, n°21-15617

You may also be interested in this news
The News by NMCG – May 2023
News By NMCG
The News by NMCG - May 2023
The intuitu personae clause tested by a change of control or management of one of the contracting companies
Article
The intuitu personae clause tested by a change of control or management of one of the contracting companies
Legislative and case law developments for “Dark stores” and “Dark kitchens
Article
Legislative and case law developments for "Dark stores" and "Dark kitchens
Unfair competition: borrowing elements of a communication is protectable […]
Article
Unfair competition: borrowing elements of a communication is protectable [...]
Interpretation of approval clauses prior to the reform of June 24, 2004 […].
Article
Interpretation of approval clauses prior to the reform of June 24, 2004 [...].
Bank’s duty to warn […].
Article
Bank's duty to warn [...].
Presumption of resignation in the event of voluntary abandonment of post by employee comes into force on April 19, 2023
Article
Presumption of resignation in the event of voluntary abandonment of post by employee comes into force on April 19, 2023
New ruling by the French Supreme Court on moral harassment
Article
New ruling by the French Supreme Court on moral harassment
Employers can use anonymous testimony to prove employee misconduct
Article
Employers can use anonymous testimony to prove employee misconduct
Clarifications from the Cour de cassation on the renunciation of the DS mandate
Article
Clarifications from the Cour de cassation on the renunciation of the DS mandate
Lawyer profile : Claire Peroux
Inside NMCG
Lawyer profile : Claire Peroux
Sub-leasing of commercial premises
Article
Sub-leasing of commercial premises
Non-compliance with the GDPR is a new ground for cancellation of a contract
Article
Non-compliance with the GDPR is a new ground for cancellation of a contract
Application of the new law to unilateral promises made before the reform of February 16, 2016
Article
Application of the new law to unilateral promises made before the reform of February 16, 2016
The acquisition of shares by the company following the refusal of approval of a transfer to a third party
Article
The acquisition of shares by the company following the refusal of approval of a transfer to a third party
An anxiety-depressive disorder can suspend the statute of limitations on an action to contest a dismissal
Article
An anxiety-depressive disorder can suspend the statute of limitations on an action to contest a dismissal
The Distinctions